What is the best Electric Ice Fishing Auger for 2023? we compare the Eskimo E40 Composite vs. Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite
In the world of Lithium field electric ice augers, making the right choice has become more accessible than ever. We'll be comparing two models in this review: the Eskimo 8" E40 Composite and the Strikemaster 8" 40V Lite Flite. and we'll delve into the details to help you make an informed decision.
Price:
Before diving into the specs, let's address one of the most critical factors for many buyers: price.
8” Eskimo E40 Composite: $459.99 vs 8” Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite: $649.99.
The Eskimo E40 Composite comes in at a more budget-friendly price, offering a significant saving compared to the Strikemaster. Now, let's get into the nitty-gritty details.
Weight:
Eskimo's Featherlight Advantage
Weight plays a pivotal role in ice auger selection, impacting portability and energy conservation. Here's how the two models stack up:
8” Eskimo E40 Composite weighs 13.9lbs vs Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite Heavier at 21lbs.
Speed:
Speed is crucial for efficient ice fishing, let’s see how the Eskimo E40 Composite and Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite test out at in the speed category.
8” Eskimo E40 Composite 3.4IPS VS Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite slower at 2.2IPS
Eskimo E40 Composite: Drills at a rate of 3.4 inches of ice per second.
Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite: Operates at 2.2 inches of ice per second.
While the difference may not seem substantial, it can make a noticeable impact when drilling multiple holes throughout the day. Faster drilling means you can cover more ground and be more productive on the ice.
Efficiency:
Efficiency, measured in inches of ice per battery charge, is another crucial consideration. Here's how these two models compare: - Spoiler, when you factor in cost it’s a draw.
Eskimo E40 Composite: provides 1300 inches of ice per charge. Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite: Offers 1600 inches of ice per charge. And with the lower up front cost of the Eskimo, this category is a draw when comparing apples to apples.
Cost of Ownership:
When evaluating ice augers, it's essential to consider not just the up front cost, but also the cost of additional accessories. Here's a breakdown of the cost of backup batteries and replacement blades for both models:
Eskimo 8" E40 Composite: $239.98 VS Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite: $306.48
Backup Battery: $243.99
Replacement Blades: $62.49 Total: $306.48
Backup Battery (if not part of a promotion): $199.99
Replacement Blades: $39.99 Total: $239.98
Eskimo's cost-effective approach to accessories and maintenance makes it an attractive option for those looking to save while still enjoying the benefits of a high-quality electric auger.
Versatility:
Both the Eskimo E40 Composite and Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite have forward and reverse drilling options. However, Eskimo takes a slight edge with its variable speed trigger.
The variable speed trigger on the Eskimo auger enhances precision control, reducing ice and slush splatter, and making it adaptable to various fishing scenarios. For Strikemaster the inclusion of a variable speed trigger in this category would have been beneficial. Having the ability to tap into the Eskimo E40’s speed while running and gunning out on the ice, and throttle down inside the wheelhouse so you are not throwing ice and slush all over your floor and walls. Speed is great but not inside the house making the E40 a great option for wheelhouse owners as well as run and gun style ice trollers!
Cutting Style:
The choice of cutting style in an ice auger can significantly impact performance. Here's a breakdown of the cutting styles for both models:
Twin Shaver Style Blades with Centering Point and Safety Ring
Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite:
Twin Curved Blades with Centering Point
Eskimo's twin shaver-style blades excel at both drilling new holes and re-opening frozen-over holes. The safety ring guides the auger through old holes, making it suitable for various ice conditions.
Strikemaster's twin curved blades and centering point are effective for new hole drilling, but they may not be as efficient for re-opening frozen-over holes compared to Eskimo's design.
Warranty:
Warranty coverage provides peace of mind and reflects the manufacturer's confidence in the product's quality. Here's a summary of the warranty information for both models:
Power Head and Auger Bit: 5-year warranty
Battery and Charger: 3-year warranty
Eskimo offers an excellent warranty, with comprehensive coverage for critical components.
Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite:
Motor: 2-year limited warranty
Battery and Charger: 2-year limited warranty
Strikemaster's warranty, while 1-3 year shorter in duration, still provides coverage for essential components.
In conclusion, the Eskimo E40 Composite and Strikemaster 40V Lite Flite will both get you to the bottom of the hole and fish top-side . Eskimo shines in terms of weight, price, versatility, cost of ownership, and warranty in this head to head match up.